2026年7月30日 星期四

克里斯多福諾蘭《奧德賽》影評:‘The Odyssey’ Review: Passion in Every Frame:每一格都飽含激情,很少有導演能將藝術電影與商業大片完美融合。.... 古典學者艾蜜莉·威爾森(Emily Wilson)批評為缺乏荷馬原著中立體、狡黠與多變的人性慾望,淪為單純因罪疚感驅使的焦慮英雄。核心批評重點 剝奪複雜性:原著中的奧德修斯遊走於英雄主義與卑劣求生之間,充滿各種算計、情慾與生存渴望;電影則將其壓扁成「為當英雄而深陷罪疚」的平板動作主角。 缺乏感官與肉身感:威爾森在《倫敦書評》指出,片中不僅缺乏深刻的情感與性愛張力,連食物等細節也缺乏真實的肉身感與誘惑。 女性群像扁平:原著中潘妮洛普等角色的政治智慧與主體性能動性被抹去,淪為單純思念丈夫的符號或功能性角色。“我研究的白人民族主義者喜愛荷馬的《奧德賽》,因為他們認為這部作品表達了外國人的本質以及獨立於男性之外的女性的本質。”

 

《奧德賽》影評推薦


《奧德賽》影評:每一格都飽含激情


很少有導演能像克里斯多福諾蘭一樣,將藝術電影與商業大片完美融合。



麥特戴蒙身著粗布長袍,站在身著淺色長袍的讚達亞面前。


麥特戴蒙飾演奧德修斯,贊達亞飾演雅典娜,出自克里斯多福諾蘭執導的《奧德賽》。圖片來源…

Critic’s Pick

‘The Odyssey’ Review: Passion in Every Frame

Few directors close the divide between the art film and the blockbuster like Christopher Nolan.

Listen · 11:34 min
Matt Damon, in a rough robe, stands in front of Zendaya, in a lighter robe.
Matt Damon as Odysseus and Zendaya as Athena in “The Odyssey,” directed by Christopher Nolan.Credit...

克里斯多福·諾蘭(Christopher Nolan)執導的電影《奧德賽》(The Odyssey)中,由麥特·戴蒙飾演的主角奧德修斯被古典學者艾蜜莉·威爾森(Emily Wilson)批評為缺乏荷馬原著中立體、狡黠與多變的人性慾望,淪為單純因罪疚感驅使的焦慮英雄。 [1, 2]
核心批評重點
  • 剝奪複雜性:原著中的奧德修斯遊走於英雄主義與卑劣求生之間,充滿各種算計、情慾與生存渴望;電影則將其壓扁成「為當英雄而深陷罪疚」的平板動作主角。
  • 缺乏感官與肉身感:威爾森在《倫敦書評》指出,片中不僅缺乏深刻的情感與性愛張力,連食物等細節也缺乏真實的肉身感與誘惑。
  • 女性群像扁平:原著中潘妮洛普等角色的政治智慧與主體性能動性被抹去,淪為單純思念丈夫的符號或功能性角色。 [1, 2, 3]
如果你想深入探討,我可以為你說明:
  • 荷馬原著與諾蘭電影在對待神話與神明上的差異
  • 威爾森對該片反戰立場與暴力美學衝突的具體批判






nationalist.  "The white nationalists"白人民族主義者.   by and large, suffice (it) to say, liberal, 以全新的視角評論諾蘭的《奧德賽》與過去的束縛 -


“我研究的白人民族主義者喜愛荷馬的《奧德賽》,因為他們認為這部作品表達了外國人的本質以及獨立於男性之外的女性的本質。”
"The white nationalists I study love Homer’s Odyssey for what they believe it expresses about the nature of foreigners and about women who live independently of men."
WHITE PEDESTAL author Curtis Dozier critiques Nolan's 'The Odyssey' from a new lens:
《白人基座》作者柯蒂斯多齊爾以全新的視角評論了諾蘭的《奧德賽》

諾蘭的《奧德賽》與過去的束縛 - 《匹茲堡書評》

White nationalism is a political and ideological movement that advocates for the preservation of a white national majority, often promoting the creation of a white ethnostate and opposing immigration and multiculturalism. [1, 2]
Core Ideology
  • Definition: The belief that white people constitute a distinct race that should maintain dominance and demographic majority in historically white countries. [1, 2]
  • Goals: Stricter immigration limits, racial separatism, or the mass deportation of non-white populations (remigration) to establish a "white-only" state. [1, 2]
  • Connection to Supremacism: Analysts and civil rights organizations, such as the Southern Poverty Law Center, note that white nationalism heavily overlaps with or acts as a sanitized euphemism for white supremacy. [1, 2]
Recent Activity and Groups
  • Patriot Front: A prominent neo-fascist and white nationalist organization founded in 2017. The group is known for flash-mob style demonstrations, distributing propaganda, and wearing standardized uniforms of khaki pants and dark shirts with face coverings. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Washington, D.C. Marches: Masked members of the Patriot Front drew widespread national attention and sparked intense public debate when they marched through Washington, D.C., carrying American and Confederate flags during the country's 250th independence anniversary celebrations. A viral photograph of a Black woman composedly riding the metro surrounded by masked members became a defining image of the event, highlighting ongoing racial tensions and the public visibility of extremist groups. [1, 2, 3]







沒有留言:

網誌存檔